Overview

Nestled in the heart of Scranton, South Carolina, Cartoni's Pizza offers a genuine taste of Italian tradition that feels both authentic and inviting. This pizza restaurant, located conveniently on US-52, serves up a menu that honors classic Italian flavors while catering to the local palate. The experience is straightforward yet satisfying—order at the counter or by phone, with prompt and courteous service ensuring a smooth visit.

The appeal of Cartoni's lies in its commitment to fresh, quality ingredients. Their dough is prepared daily, contributing to the perfect crust that customers repeatedly praise. Whether you select a classic pepperoni pizza or opt for one of their hearty specials like the Ribeye Steak plate or Bone-in Pork Chop with traditional sides, you’ll find the balance of flavor and comfort impeccable. The pizza toppings range from staple favorites like sausage and green peppers to more nuanced selections such as banana peppers and olives, offering a customizable yet classic experience.

Salads like the Antipasto and Greek with house-made dressings provide a refreshing counterpoint to the rich main dishes, perfect for those who seek a lighter option without sacrificing taste. Regulars note the generous portions and fresh ingredients, like ample feta on the Greek Salad, making it a standout.

The atmosphere caters to both families and individuals looking for a genuine Italian meal in a relaxed, no-frills setting. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming vibe, striking the right balance between attentive and unobtrusive service. Thanks to its proximity to Lake City and Scranton locals, Cartoni’s has quickly become a cherished spot for those craving true Italian comfort food without the fuss.

In sum, Cartoni’s Pizza is a reliable gem that blends traditional Italian cuisine with down-to-earth hospitality. It is perfect for anyone who values great taste, fresh preparation, and fair prices in a casual environment. Whether stopping by for a quick slice, a full meal, or ordering delivery to your door, this Scranton favorite delivers consistently on flavor and experience.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Quiet

What Customers Say

Tracy Count
Feb 16,2026
5/5
If you love the pizza from Stefano’s, then Cartoni’s won’t let you down. Some true authentic Italian food. Antipasto salad is a little different than Stefano’s, it has bell pepper and iceberg lettuce, but still delicious. The baked bread with marinara was mouth watering. Philly cheese didn’t disappoint. More convenient to Lake City.
M, Kline (Madje)
Feb 16,2026
5/5
We're from PA originally, and finding GOOD pizza (non-bitter sauce, firm & stone-baked dough) is difficult in SC. We had slices only but were impressed. Well, Cartoni's is a winner for us! An employee said dough is made fresh daily. They need wait staff so you order at the counter entrance or by phone. Turns out the owner is from the Reading, PA area & used to own Ozzy's Family Fun Center on Route 61 outside of Leesport (my hubby's hometown).
Daniel Kuhns
Feb 16,2026
5/5
Was in the area so I stopped. Nice place, I ordered a Stromboli special. It was awesome. I haven't had Italian this good in a long time. The crust was perfectly done, the Stromboli was almost 2' long. Had a great taste and the sauce did not disappoint. The pricing was very fair. If ur close check this place out for sure.
Mandy Buchanan
Feb 16,2026
5/5
My family loves Cartoni's! The staff is so nice and the food is great. My favorite is the Greek Salad with house dressing (oil and vinegar). It's a big salad with lots of feta cheese! So good! Their meatballs are wonderful, too.
Fred W
Feb 16,2026
5/5
We love experimenting with local restaurants and especially live finding gems like this! Appetizers, specials, entrees, pizza all top notch and at great prices! The service was great too. Not too clingy but timely. We'll be back and recommend you try it too!

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Top Picks for You

More in Scranton, South Carolina, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!